Is Cooper Rush overrated, underrated, or simply the ideal QB2 for the Cowboys?

When Cooper Rush was thrown into the fire in Week 1 of last season, expectations were low. Previous to 2022, Rush only had one career start to his name. Over the course of those four previous seasons, he was 31 for 50, throwing for 424 yards and posting a career QBR under 41 (well below average).

So when Rush went 4-1 in place of the injured Dak Prescott early last season, just about everyone experienced some degree of surprise. Rush didn’t light the world on fire, but he did enough to get the job done for the Cowboys.

As a result of his success in 2022, it was believed the Cowboys would have a difficult time retaining their season-saving QB2.

Rush entered free agency in March, coming off the best season of his career but he didn’t garner the interest many thought he would on the open market.

After testing the lukewarm waters of free agency, Rush reupped with Dallas, signing a 2-year, $5 million deal to reclaim his role as Prescott’s top back-up.

Given the lack of interest in free agency it begs the question: Was Rush overrated in Dallas?

Even for a back-up spot, Rush’s contract was modest by most standards. It stands to reason the demand wasn’t much for the 30-year-old QB and he wasn’t viewed to be quite the asset nationally as he was locally.

The numbers seem to validate such an idea. While his win-loss record (4-1) and touchdown to interception ratio (5-3) looked strong, his adjusted yards gained per pass attempt (AY/A) dropped to a paltry 6.3, his yards/g sat at 116.8 and his QBR ended at 58.7.

Advanced stats were also fairly meager. In expected points added plus completion percentage over expected (EPA+CPOE composite) Rush’s 0.009 came in at 44^th in the NFL last season, placing him right in the middle of QB2 territory.

Rush posted just a 42.6 success rate, which placed him at 38^th in the NFL and his adjusted EPA/p was 0.006 which ranked him 32^nd (Prescott was top-10 in all categories).

At the end of the day, Rush looked like a back-up QB, both on film and by the numbers. He took care of the football and was able to make a few big plays here and there, but primarily he just let the defense carry the load and took advantage of situations when they presented themselves.

He may not be someone who’s going to win games but he’s someone who knows how to play within himself and won’t lose games either. On a team like the Cowboys who have an elite defense and homerun hitters on offense, he fits nicely.

On a less talented team where the QB is needed to do heavy lifting to compete, he doesn’t fit as well.

Which explains the tepid reception he was given in free agency.

Whether he’s overrated, underrated or appropriately valued depends on everyone’s individual expectations for Rush. It’s safe to say there are only a handful of teams in the NFL Rush could have gone 4-1 with because it’s hard to win in this league with a QB who consistently throws for under 200 yards/g.

But on the Cowboys, he’s a great fit. The team knows what they’re getting from Rush and can formulate the proper gameplan to win with him. Rush knows his defense and the playmakers around him can get the job done so he doesn’t have to feel the pressure to press. It’s a perfect marriage because of the familiarity between player and team.

Overrated?

Underrated?

Who cares? It’s a good fit.

An offer for Cowboys fans

For the best local Austin news, sports, entertainment and culture coverage, subscribe to the Austin American-Statesman.

More!

Cowboys News: How high in top 10 is Dak? Gambling site battles

Replacing Dalton Schultz will be no small task for the Cowboys

Cowboys legends Tony Dorsett, Drew Pearson team with Washington rival for special HS practice

Story originally appeared on Cowboys Wire